🎯 Insider Buy Accuracy — Historical Track Record

How accurate are insider buys? Multi-horizon analysis vs S&P 500 benchmark.

🔄 Last update: 11/17/2026 at 14:20 UTC
Hit Rate (90d)
70%
153 buys evaluated at 90d
Buys Evaluated
219
buys evaluated
Avg. Alpha (90d)
+4.1%
vs S&P 500
Avg. Return (90d)
+9.8%
90d avg

📈 Return vs S&P 500 by Horizon

\n 0.0%\n \n 2.5%\n \n 4.9%\n \n 7.4%\n \n 9.8%\n \n 30d\n 60d\n 90d\n 180d\n \n \n \n \n +5.0%\n \n +9.1%\n \n +9.8%\n \n +5.4%\n \n \n \n \n \n Insider Buys\n \n S&P 500\n
Horizon Evaluated Hit Rate (90d) Avg. Return S&P 500 Alpha
30d 177 72% +5.0% +2.9% +2.1%
60d 168 74% +9.1% +4.3% +4.8%
90d 153 70% +9.8% +5.7% +4.1%
180d 124 74% +5.4% +9.5% -4.1%

📊 Accuracy by Insider Role

Role Buys Evaluated Hit Rate (90d) Alpha (90d)
CFO 2 1 100% +91.2%
Officer 1 1 100% +25.1%
CEO 57 34 91% +11.8%
10% Owner 78 70 73% +2.5%
CTO 76 45 51% -0.8%
Other 2 2 0% -12.8%

📊 Accuracy by Sector

Sector Buys Evaluated Hit Rate (90d) Alpha (90d)
Materials 1 1 100% +13.3%
Consumer Discretionary 42 42 86% +12.4%
Healthcare 9 8 75% +5.8%
Financials 92 75 72% +2.4%
Technology 28 9 22% -3.1%
Real Estate 16 14 50% -5.5%
Other 16 1 0% -6.1%
Industrials 9 2 50% -6.5%
Communication Services 1 1 0% -8.4%

🏆 Top Performing Tickers by Alpha

Ticker Buys Evaluated Hit Rate (90d) Avg. Return Alpha
INTC 3 2 50% +26.0% +26.9%
PYPL 1 1 100% +26.4% +25.1%
ADBE 1 1 100% +26.9% +21.4%
PFE 3 3 100% +17.1% +19.5%
RIVN 6 6 83% +20.5% +17.9%
TSLA 26 26 100% +22.8% +17.8%
SBUX 1 1 100% +17.6% +16.1%
LIN 1 1 100% +10.9% +13.3%
GS 45 45 84% +14.4% +5.2%
SOFI 4 4 75% +6.3% +0.3%

📐 Methodology

We evaluate every open-market insider purchase (SEC Form 4, code "P") by measuring stock price performance at 30, 60, 90, and 180 days after the buy. Each return is compared to the S&P 500 index over the same period to calculate alpha (outperformance). Only buys with sufficient time elapsed are included in the evaluation.

❓ Frequently Asked Questions

What is insider buy accuracy?

It measures how often a stock price goes up after an insider (executive, director, or major shareholder) makes an open-market purchase. A hit rate above 50% means insiders are right more often than not.

What is alpha?

Alpha is the difference between the stock's return and the S&P 500 return over the same period. Positive alpha means insider buys outperformed the general market.

How is this calculated?

For each insider buy, we compare the stock price on the buy date to the price at +30, +60, +90, and +180 days. We then calculate the average return and compare it to the S&P 500 benchmark.

Why do insiders outperform?

Insiders have deep knowledge of their company's operations, pipeline, and prospects. When they voluntarily invest their own money, it often signals genuine confidence in the company's future — information advantage that academic research has consistently documented.

⚠️ Disclaimer: WhaleSentiment provides public SEC data for informational and educational purposes only. It does not provide financial advice, investment recommendations, or solicitation to buy/sell financial instruments. Always consult a qualified financial advisor before making investment decisions.